Adam Hoelscher

Just awful

Revisado: 09-15-20

Both the writing and the performance of this work are terrible.

The author has no coherence and very little substance. Not a single term she defines is used in a consistent way throughout the book. She switches constantly and unpredictably between "Jealousy will destroy your very soul" and "A little jealousy is a good thing". She also switches inexplicably between the vantage point of the jealous partner and the one to whom the jealousy is being directed. Liberal use of unclear pronouns make those situations nearly incomprehensible. There is dangerous advice given that one should alter one's behavior to keep their partner from being jealous.

The narrator mispronounces dozens of words during the grueling 3:14 of the book, even though nothing in the book is written above about an 8th grade reading level. There were several times that I had to rewind 10 seconds and listen to a sentence again just to try to infer what word she was butchering.

Either the author, the narrator, or both have fundamental incomprehension of the English language. There are multiple dozens of fragmented or grammatically unparseable sentences. The phrase "the underlining issue" is used half a dozen times and not to describe a problem with the formatting of a printed document.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 6 personas

So-so reading of a great text.

Revisado: 07-26-18

Having listened to books 1-4 as read by Frank Mueller, I can't help but notice the flatness of Guidall's character voices. It's hard to tell which character is which during quick exchanges. that said, the story is amazing and I can't wait to finish the series, bad voice acting or not.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña