-
HVT-002 The Honor of the Queen
- Oct 2 2022
- Duración: 1 h y 48 m
- Podcast
No se pudo agregar al carrito
Add to Cart failed.
Error al Agregar a Lista de Deseos.
Error al eliminar de la lista de deseos.
Error al añadir a tu biblioteca
Error al seguir el podcast
Error al dejar de seguir el podcast
-
Resumen
Lo que los oyentes dicen sobre HVT-002 The Honor of the Queen
Calificaciones medias de los clientesReseñas - Selecciona las pestañas a continuación para cambiar el origen de las reseñas.
-
Total
-
Ejecución
-
Historia
- Edqp
- 09-25-24
The Discussion is Mostly Good, But...
The overall discussion is good and the topics discussed are great. However, it's grating how we have a fanboy who chimes in and sort-of sounds like, "Shart" from 'The Mayor of Noobtown' (LitRPG). Then we have some guy who it's evident he's not interested. He can't even read the dang book well enough to truly participate in the discussion and the other two guys have to carry and prod him along. The 3rd guy is okay in my book.
Se ha producido un error. Vuelve a intentarlo dentro de unos minutos.
Has calificado esta reseña.
Reportaste esta reseña
-
Total
-
Ejecución
-
Historia
- Russ
- 09-11-23
5/5
Ok. This was definitely better than OBS. Moved into the action and drama quite a bit faster.
As I listened to this episode, I had a realization. I used to feel largely the same way 2/3rds of your podcast did about the extended cast of characters. When I picked up the audio books I noticed that I actually enjoyed the books more then I used to. I originally thought that I just wasn’t giving sections of the book a proper shake until the format change forced me to. And maybe that is part of it... But I am becoming convinced that these books are Better during a reread.
White Haven barely had a part in the first book. Here he gets roughly 3 or 4 scenes, twice what he had before. But not enough to really do anything with. Despite that the characters remain themselves as the story goes forward. Reading these small section with the retrospective knowledge of the characters makes them feel so much more important because I’m already hooked on them.
I have a distinct memory of not really being able to keep track of the smaller characters book to book. The book you’re reading will gently remind you where you know the character from and proceed apiece. If you remember them you’re rewarded because their Essential Selves remain consistent while their internal narrative has continued to progress.
This, if I’m correct, is definitely a weakness of the series because it’s harder upon new readers. This is an aspect of Weber’s writing that I feel like was much better done in a newer (but still massive) series he’s worked on called Safehold. In that series I feel like Weber does a better job waiting to introduce characters when they have a more substantial part to play. After I finish this part of the Honorverse I think I’ll go back to Safehold to check.
Regardless, I deeply love how Weber scuffled viewpoints as the story unfolded. We go back and forth, hearing what they think of each other and what they deduce, then the viewpoint reverses an we get new details. Particularly where the Manticorians and Graysons were figuring each other out And where the Havenites and the Masadans were constantly attempting to work around the other. Listening to the Havenites think about how stupid and backwards the Masadans are, on,y to get the Masadans thinking about how gullible the Havenites are while being blind to things the Havenites think are obvious. Fascinating.
Regarding Honor’s injuries, they a,punt they came out really didn’t start out to me. It felt like it came up when She would’ve been thinking of it. But this is my fourth time through the book. I’ll also admit to a certain fascination with her injuries the first time I read through it. I may have been just the right age for it to not take me out of the story.
Regarding the possible template.... eh, not really. It’s the most true at the front of the series, but then the various genera chicks we occasionally see plus the advancing plot lines and seniority of our protagonist does a good job shaking things up. The biggest thing is, you can usually be pretty sure Honor will get through the situation, but that usually doesn’t prevent things from becoming pretty tense.
My favorite scenes this book has, the scenes I remember years between reads, are the scene where Honor and Nimitz throw hands, and the scene where Honor has classical music piped through the ship systems in their darkest hour. No matter how long I go before a reread, those scenes Stick.
5/5. Easy. As I sit here, for the first time really critically thinking through this series I’ve loved for so long, I think This might be My favorite Honor Harrington book. I’ve always thought Echo of Honor, or Ashes of Victory were my favorite. But really thinking it through, This book might take it. I’m exited to examine these thought as we go forwards.
Se ha producido un error. Vuelve a intentarlo dentro de unos minutos.
Has calificado esta reseña.
Reportaste esta reseña