Is opera the pinnacle of high culture, or a boring anachronism?

One of us has enjoyed some excellent recent operas at Covent Garden, the other’s exposure to the artform was a single regrettable unstaged Wagner playthrough at the Albert Hall. Both of us have had a couple of drinks.

The problem is that opera is not really an English artform - the Royal Opera House was better known for pantomime until surprisingly recently, and pantomime is an English artform, and it’s fun, and it taps into a deep lake of tradition, and you can bring in popcorn and it’s participatory. Opera is a stuffy German and Italian tradition, and English opera lovers tend to act in a very German or Italian way, like shouting bravo after a well-sung aria, and that’s pretty embarrassing.

It’s also a relic of a time before electronics. If you want a spectacle, watch Dune in the IMAX. If you want a live spectacle, go to a UFC event or a Sleep Token gig. It’s telling that all the good contemporary composers work in film now - opera is a museum piece watched by old people and only kept alive by enormous state subsidy.

But high culture is important. A lot of excellence has to come together at the same place and time to deliver an opera performance - the best singers and dancers in the world, above the best orchestra and conductor in the world, supported by the best lighting designer, set designer and director in the world, playing music by one of the best composers of all time, and all these people are trying to push the boundaries and create something that transcends the everyday. You are drowning in IRL excellence in a way that is hard to experience in any other context, and if you commit to it it can take you places low culture cannot.

Yes it’s inaccessible, unashamedly so. Excellence is hard to appreciate without a great deal of relevant knowledge and experience, and it takes time and effort to build this. But there’s real virtue in cultivating the ability to be able to recognise excellence when you see it, and then to enjoy it.

So if only for this reason, we’d say opera is worth a try - perhaps with two glasses of wine beforehand.