On this episode of Three Tool Players, we each give the definitive versions of who is on the Mount Rushmore for each of our teams, the Mets, Phillies and Yankees. Also, who do you want standing behind you in a barroom brawl? The ’86 Mets? The ’93 Phillies? Or Derek Jeter? All this and more on this episode of Three Tool Players.

On this episode we play a new game called “Who Would You Rather” where we debate dramatic scenarios and which player we’d want for them. We also debate positional battles like Willie Mays vs. The Kid and The Wizard of Oz vs The Captain. Plus why you need to watch the Baseball Bunch! All this and more on this episode of Three Tool Players!

On this episode of Three Tool Players, we talk about the who, what and especially why of the Rafael Devers trade. Also, what was the value for both the Red Sox and Giants, was Devers a true Yankees killer, Brian needs a research staff, and the Hammers give a tribute to their dad. All this and more on this episode of Three Tool Players.

On this episode of Three Tool Players, we cast our votes for the starters of the 2025 American League All-Star team. Brian loses a bet because he’s a homer, Dan put his special gifts on display, and Spear looks forward to a clam bake down the shore, all this and more on this episode of Three Tool Player!

On this episode of Three Tool Players, MLB All-Star balloting is open and we’re ready with our starters in the field and on the mound for the National League. There may be a stuffing of the ballot box in Pittsburgh, Shohei Ohtani is very good at baseball and we discuss the worst players to ever take the field for the National League, all this and more on this episode of Three Tool Players!

On this episode of Three Tool Players, we debate questions around baseball with our favorite segment True or False. Is the AL East the most disappointing? Did the Phillies make a mistake trading Kody Clemens? Is Freddie Freeman a first-ballot Hall of Famer? And who is or isn’t a good boy when it comes to PEDs?

We’re at the one-third mark of the season and we each give some rest of the season predictions for the Mets, Phillies and Yankees. Spear tries his hand at optimism, Dan wants some bullpen help, and Brian tempts the baseball gods.

On this episode, Jose Alvarado gets caught taking PEDs for swimsuit season, Spear warns Dan of hubris with thinking the Phillies have too much starting pitching, Juan Soto gets mercilessly booed in the Bronx and Brian has a new business model for baseball team consultants.