Originally posted as Episode 91 on Feb. 20, 2020. 

Amanda and Sarah say screw it and try to scare the crap out of each other by tapping into their deepest fearscinations. Sarah gets into Amanda's frog/toad phobia with a look at the Loveland Frog and similar accounts from Ohio and other places. Amanda scoured Reddit and other sites for the creepiest, most disturbing, user-submitted doppelganger encounters. Other subjects covered include SWEET POTATO SKINS, horror daddies, and another ghoulish musical.

Recommendations:

Sarah recommends the latest season of the show Chilling Adventures of Sabrina and does not recommend the indie horror film, Pyewacket. Amanda adds her vote for watching the HBO show The Outsider.

Sources:

• The Weiser Field Guide to Cryptozoology: Werewolves, Dragons, Skyfish, Lizard Men, and Other Fascinating Creatures Real and Mysterious Paperback by Deena West Budd
• The Singular Fortean Society (The Loveland Frogmen)
• Exemplore (The Loveland Frog: Monster, Alien, or Escaped Pet?)
• Wikipedia/Joint-eater
• Snopes (‘Loveland Frogman’ Spotted Again?)
• CINCY Weekend (Everything You Need To Know About The Loveland Frog, Cincy’s Wildest Urban Legend)
• Cincinnati.com
• True Horror Stories of Texas (Doppelganger)
• Ranker (People Share Creepy Stories Of Encounters With Doppelgangers)
• Mysterious Universe (Sinister Encounters with Evil Doppelgängers)

For updates on future episodes and other fun stuff, follow us on Twitter and Instagram.