Episodes

  • What If the United States Invaded and Annexed Mexico in the 19th Century? // 06
    Jan 23 2025

    In the 19th century, the relationship between the United States and Mexico was marked by territorial disputes and conflict, culminating in the Mexican-American War (1846-1848). But what if, instead of stopping at the annexation of Texas and the acquisition of northern territories, the United States had invaded and annexed the entirety of Mexico? This episode explores the political, social, and economic ramifications of such a monumental event.

    References

    1. YouTube Video: The Mexican-American War: A Brief History by History Scope. Published on March 10, 2021.
    2. Book: Manifest Destiny and Empire: The United States and Mexico in the 19th Century by James P. McClellan. Published in 2018.
    3. Journal Article: “The Annexation Debate: Slavery, Politics, and Territorial Expansion” from The American Historical Review. Published in December 2019.
    4. YouTube Video: What If the U.S. Annexed Mexico? by AlternateHistoryHub. Published on June 15, 2020.
    5. Documentary: Empire of Liberty: U.S. Expansion in the 19th Century. Produced by PBS, released in 2017.

    Show more Show less
    14 mins
  • What If the Aztecs Had Defeated the Spanish Conquistadors? // 05
    Jan 21 2025

    The fall of the Aztec Empire in 1521 marked a turning point in world history, leading to the Spanish colonization of the Americas. But what if the Aztecs had turned the tide and repelled Hernán Cortés and his forces? This episode explores an alternate reality where the Aztecs emerged victorious, delving into how their survival might have reshaped the Americas. Would the Aztecs have expanded their empire, forming alliances with neighboring tribes? Could they have resisted European colonization entirely? Join us as we reimagine a world where the Aztec civilization thrived into modern times.

    References

    1. YouTube Video: The Aztec Empire - Rise and Fall | Full Documentary by The History Chronicles. Published on April 15, 2021.
    2. Book: 1491: New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus by Charles C. Mann. Published in 2005.
    3. Article: "The Spanish Conquest of the Aztec Empire" by World History Encyclopedia. Last updated March 10, 2022.
    4. Journal: "Aztec Warfare and Resistance Strategies Against Conquistadors" by Dr. Maria Lopez. Published in Latin American Studies Quarterly, Volume 47, 2019.
    5. Podcast: History Extra: The Conquest of Mexico. Episode released on October 3, 2020.

    Show more Show less
    27 mins
  • What If the South Had Won the Civil War? // 04
    Jan 16 2025

    What if the Confederacy had triumphed in the American Civil War? This alternate history explores the ripple effects of a Southern victory, from a divided United States to the potential global impacts of a prolonged slave-based economy. Would the Union and Confederacy have coexisted peacefully, or would new conflicts have emerged? How might this alternate timeline have shaped world wars, civil rights movements, and modern geopolitics? Join us as we delve into a thought-provoking journey through one of history’s greatest "what ifs."

    References:

    1. YouTube Video: "Alternate History: What If the South Won the Civil War?" by History Matters. Published on March 2, 2020.
    2. Book: "If the South Had Won the Civil War" by MacKinlay Kantor. Published in 1960.
    3. Article: "The Confederate States of America: A Speculative History" by American Historical Review. Published on May 15, 2015.
    4. Documentary: "The American Civil War: A Nation Divided" by PBS. Released in 2015.
    5. YouTube Video: "How the Confederacy Could Have Survived" by AlternateHistoryHub. Published on January 8, 2018.

    Show more Show less
    17 mins
  • What If Christopher Columbus Never Discovered the Americas? // 03
    Jan 13 2025

    Listen on Spotify

    Listen on Apple Podcasts

    Listen on YouTube

    Christopher Columbus's 1492 voyage to the Americas is often heralded as a pivotal moment in world history. But what if Columbus had never made his journey? In this episode of What If It Went Differently?, we explore an alternate timeline where the Americas remained undiscovered by European powers for decades or even centuries. How would this delay have shaped the course of world history, including the development of empires, the spread of diseases, and the lives of Indigenous peoples? Would another explorer have stepped into Columbus's place, or would the Americas have remained untouched by European influence for much longer? Join us as we rewrite history and reimagine the future of a world without Columbus's fateful voyage.

    References:

    1. YouTube Video: The Columbian Exchange - Transforming the World | Full Documentary by History Unfolded. Published on March 12, 2020.
    2. Book: 1491: New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus by Charles C. Mann. Published in 2005.
    3. Article: "The Age of Exploration and Its Impact on Global Trade" by the History Research Center. Published in May 2019.
    4. Journal: European Historical Review: "Alternate Histories of the New World." Published in October 2017.
    5. Documentary: The Untold Story of Indigenous America by National Geographic. Published on June 10, 2021.


    Show more Show less
    23 mins
  • What If the United States Had Lost the Revolutionary War? // 02
    Jan 10 2025

    Listen on Spotify

    Listen on Apple Podcasts

    Listen on YouTube

    The Revolutionary War marked the birth of the United States as an independent nation, but what if the British had emerged victorious? This scenario explores an alternate history where the American colonies remained under British control. Key revolutionary leaders like George Washington and Thomas Jefferson might have been executed for treason, while the colonies could have continued under British governance, delaying or even preventing the development of democratic institutions. Slavery might have ended earlier, avoiding the Civil War, as Britain abolished slavery in the early 19th century. Economically, the colonies could have faced harsher taxes and restricted trade under British mercantilist policies, stifling growth. Westward expansion might have been delayed or limited, drastically altering the geographic and political landscape of North America. This thought experiment reveals how different the world might be today if the United States had never gained its independence. References

    1. YouTube Video: The Revolutionary War - A British Victory | Alternate History by Historical Revisions. Published on July 4, 2020.
    2. Book: What Ifs? of American History edited by Robert Cowley. Published in 2003.
    3. Article: "The Consequences of a British Victory in the American War of Independence" by History Today. Published in February 2018.
    4. Documentary: The Revolution That Wasn't - Exploring a British Victory by National History Channel. Released in 2019.
    5. YouTube Video: Alternate History - What If Britain Won the Revolutionary War? by History Scope. Published on March 12, 2021.



    Show more Show less
    19 mins
  • What If the Axis Powers Had Won World War II? // 01
    Jan 9 2025

    Listen on Spotify

    Listen on Apple Podcasts

    Listen on YouTube


    World War II was one of the most pivotal conflicts in human history, shaping the modern world as we know it. But what if the outcome had been different? Imagine a world dominated by the Axis Powers—Germany, Italy, and Japan. How would global politics, culture, and society have evolved under their rule? Would the United States have remained a bastion of resistance, or would it have succumbed to Axis influence? Join us as we delve into an alternate history where the Axis Powers emerged victorious, exploring the far-reaching consequences of this chilling scenario.

    References

    • Book: "The Man in the High Castle" by Philip K. Dick. Published in 1962.
    • Documentary: World War II in Colour by Netflix. Released on November 11, 2009.
    • Book: "Hitler's Empire: How the Nazis Ruled Europe" by Mark Mazower. Published in 2009.
    • Article: Alternate Histories of WWII by History Extra. Published on September 2, 2017.
    • YouTube Video: The Rise of the Axis Powers - Alternate History Explained by The Armchair Historian. Published on March 12, 2022.


    Show more Show less
    21 mins