god for anylitical thinkers

Excellent summation of some of the most provocative evidence for there being much more going on in the universe than our material paradigm insists. I want it in written form so I can follow up on her resources but was entranced by it in audio format. Two minor quibbles: the narrator keeps mispronouncing "psilocybin" (which I found mildly irritating) and it gets repetitive at the end, but definitely a fully engaging listen and very possibly an eye opener for the spiritually uninitiated.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

11 people found this helpful

Beautifully written

In the pop-psychology genre there aren't a lot of women authors. Women think differently from men in a good many ways; so the amazing thing about this book, in my opinion, is that only a woman could have written a book about this subject and have done it in such a beautiful way. The hard science behind God is obviously non-existent, but does that mean that he/she is non-existent. Well that is for each individual to decide for his or herself. I recommend listening to this book if you are interested in this question and a few others. This lady does a good analysis of this subject from a semi-scientific point of view and she uses a woman's natural empathy to write a splendid pop-psychology book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Good Overview of "Spiritual Biology"

A very well done book presenting the science involved in how we have spiritual experiences. She talks about her own spiritual experience and how it drove her to find out more about how the brain works, how other experience a divine presence, etc. She also gives a good overview of the counter-arguments against these things being anything other than our brain firing in a unique way.

For those of a spiritual inclination, there are many, many stories of people encountering a divine force, and how they became important forces of change for that individual. For those not inclined, it's provides insights into why people feel the way they do, as well as a layman's view of how things happen.

The audio presentation is also well done. The reader does a good job with the material and is easy to understand.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

Impressive

Hagerty executes the nearly impossible task of reviewing a diverse array of topics with clarity and evenhandedness. Understand that this spans the current state of research and speculation about near death experiences to the influences of intention on remote subjects. It requires an exceptional mind as well as great discipline to pull this off, and Hagerty has both.

I do have two serious reservations, however, that keep this rating at four stars. First, Hagerty falls into the common scientific illiteracy of declaring human minds as somehow "wired." This inadequate description reduces reality in tune with the worst weaknesses of mainstream science, which otherwise does not fare well here.

My other objection is more serious. In her closing chapter, Hagerty struggles vainly, ignoring fact and history, to preserve Christianity. Christianity is a fine religion in many ways, but the writer's fluffy efforts to find a logical, scientific basis for retaining her beliefs is both personally slanted and objectively unconvincing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

How did she anticipate my every question?

Barbara Bradley Hagerty, a journalist and former Christian scientist, examines ongoing scientific research into the nature and significance of spiritual, paranormal, and near death experiences reported by people of diverse faith backgrounds. Unlike many books on such topics, I don't get the feeling that she is trying to sell me a particular viewpoint by deliberately filtering the information she presents. Rather, her examination of the topic is both broad and thorough, and she is honest about her own shifting perspective on God and on the particulars of her "mainstream Christian faith", at times expressing elation at her discoveries, and at others, disappointment.

What amazed me is that I have been asking these very questions for years, and not only was it satisfying to hear them all discussed in one well-written book, but I am also newly equipped with references and other resources to further support my own personal inquiries.

My only disappointment in this book was its conclusion: She ends with a rather insipid nod to Christianity that would satisfy neither a Christian reader nor a skeptic.

The ideas in this book are also informed by the author's ambivalent relationship with Christian Science, making for an interesting perspective not often represented in either scientific or popular faith-based literature.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

I was little stimulated and less entertained

What disappointed you about Fingerprints of God?

The book was highly recommended to me, so perhaps I was perhaps expecting more. I found little that was new to me and did not come away with useful insights; much of the time I felt slightly bored and impatient while listening. Perhaps I was not interested enough in the author's personal experiences. I would have preferred not to feel the author's presence so much in some of what she reports (which is not without interest — the experiences of psychic healing stand out).

Would you be willing to try another book from Barbara Bradley Hagerty? Why or why not?

Not too inclined but nonetheless open... depends on the subject matter.

What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?

I am writing this a year after I listened to it and can't remember well enough to say anything precise; I just recall feeling somewhat bored much of the time. I had to make myself listen to the end. This however may not be the fault of the reader.

Any additional comments?

After thirty years of interest in spirituality and related scientific experiments, I am becoming increasingly skeptical (much of what I once took to be supporting evidence turned out to lack substance). I am listening to Michael Shermer's 'How We Believe: The Search for God in an Age of Science' with enormous satisfaction as he answers many of the questions I have had, both regarding the validity of certain experiments and regarding the mental processes (particularly my own) involved in believing and in wanting to believe.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An Honest Examination, Some Beautiful Conclusions

I would have given the book 4.5 stars, because I do think it has its flaws, but I rounded up to 5 because it honestly was worth every penny I spent to listen to it.

As a person searching for God without sacrificing reason, my belief in the power of observation and the scientific method, or my honesty, I found Hagerty's book incredibly insightful. She surveys spiritual experience across many religions and through many people, emerging with some common denominators as to what mysticism may all be about.

The book has its slow chapters, and sometimes I got impatient with what I saw as repetitious points, but this is really nitpicking.

Overall, it was a fantastic book that changed my perception of spiritual experience - and God.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Fingerprints

Barbara B. Hagerty points out how to see God's touch in all different situations. It's amazing how much this book opened my eyes, so to speak, to the presence of God in many aspects of my everyday life.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

philip

I finish this book with more questions than I started. This is a complement to the author. The book reinforced many of my personal beliefs and it was wonderful to hear them explored with an open mind. Ms. Hagerty clearly did not have any other agenda than answers. I look forward to reading anything she writes in the future as she continues her search.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Soul Searching

This book chronicles a personal journey to understand spirituality. Told and written by a superlative journalist, but with personal candor and searching that's compelling. A wonderful listen and a beautiful story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!